I got in touch with a catering company (
Shackamaxon Catering) that helps set you up with reception sites too.
Not in any particular order yet:
1)
Snug Hollow Farm:
Website research only at the moment
Pros: only one wedding on the day so tuesday-saturday to set up, includes chairs and tables, air-conditioned barn
Cons: A little further away for New York drivers, people might have to rent a car if they don't have one or find a ride, a little more expensive than the other places, porta-potties as the bathroom
2)
Batram's Gardens:
Website research only at the moment
Pros: beautiful grounds gardens and arboretum
Cons: would also have to tent which adds a cost
3)
The National Society of the Colonial Dames of America:
Website research only at the moment
Pros: Easy access to hotels, garden for outdoor ceremony but indoor option, historic mansion, looks like blank canvas ballroom for lots of color options
Cons: Center city (might want sometime more rustic/country)
What do you think?